Health Insights

10 Surprising Foods That Are Actually Super High in Calories

10 Surprising Foods That Are Actually Super High in Calories

Posted by Portions Master on 23rd May 2025

(And Why Portion Awareness Is the Real Power Move)

When you think of high-calorie foods, your mind might go straight to burgers, fries, and sugary desserts. But some of the most deceptively calorie-dense foods are found in "health food" aisles and trendy kitchen staples.

If you're not aware of your portions, it's easy to sabotage your health goals-even when you're eating clean. That's where visual portion tracking with Portions Master makes a huge difference: no guesswork, just clear-eyed balance.

Here are 10 foods that pack serious calories per bite (even though they seem innocent or healthy):

1. Nut Butters (Peanut, Almond, Cashew)

Calories: Approximately 190-210 per 2 tablespoons

Nut butters are nutrient-rich but dangerously easy to overeat. That heaping spoonful you added to oatmeal? Probably closer to 3-4 tablespoons.

Portions Master Tip: Take a quick photo before you spread or scoop. The app can help estimate when you're going from snack to calorie bomb.

2. Coconut Products (Milk, Oil, Shredded)

Calories:

  • Coconut milk: ~450 per cup (canned)
  • Coconut oil: ~120 per tablespoon
  • · Shredded coconut: ~100 per 2 tablespoons
    Coconut is often used in smoothies, cooking, and baked goods, but it's incredibly calorie-dense due to its saturated fat content. It adds up fast without much volume.

Portions Master Tip: Use Cart-to-Recipe to break down your ingredients, especially for smoothies or sauces with coconut milk or oil.

3. Trail Mix

Calories: Around 700 per cup

A handful is fine. A bowl is a full meal. Trail mix combines nuts, dried fruit, seeds, and sometimes chocolate-all calorie dense.

Portions Master Tip: Use a visual reference in the app to stick to a ¼ cup portion.

4. Cheese

Calories: Around 110 per ounce (about one slice or two small cubes)

Cheese adds flavor and protein, but the calories stack fast, especially if you're slicing without measuring.

Portions Master Tip: Snap a pic of your cheese plate and let the app estimate the true portion.

5. Bagels

Calories: Around 250-300 per plain bagel (without toppings)

Bagels are dense and deceptively large. Add cream cheese or peanut butter, and you've built a 500-600 calorie breakfast easily.

Portions Master Tip: Opt for half and load up on protein-rich toppings to stay full longer.

6. Pasta

Calories: Approximately 200 per cooked cup (without sauce)

Pasta servings are almost always oversized-especially when eating out. A "serving" is just one cup, but most people eat 2-3 without realizing it.

Portions Master Tip: Use plate photos to estimate true portions and balance with vegetables or lean protein.

7. Granola

Calories: Around 450-500 per cup

Marketed as a "healthy" breakfast option, granola is often loaded with oils, nuts, and sugars. Even a small bowl can exceed your calorie target for the meal.

Portions Master Tip: Use the Ingredient Scanner to check the label and visually track your true portion. Try mixing granola with lower-calorie cereals for volume.

8. Nuts (Almonds, Cashews, Walnuts)

Calories: Approximately 160-200 per small handful (1 oz)

Nuts are a great snack if you don't accidentally eat half a cup. A few extra handfuls while working can equal 500-600 extra calories.

Portions Master Tip: Snap a pic of your snack bowl and check your visual log for sneaky increases.

9. Whole Milk and Full-Fat Yogurt

Calories: Around 150-180 per cup

Great for weight gain, but overpouring milk in your cereal or blending with fruit can push your breakfast into dessert territory.

Portions Master Tip: Use the app's AI to assess liquid calories in bowls, smoothies, or parfaits.

10. Smoothie Bowls

Calories: 400-700 depending on ingredients and toppings

They look fresh and Instagram-worthy, but smoothie bowls often include multiple servings of fruit, sweetened yogurt, nut butter, granola, and seeds-all blended into a calorie-packed meal.

Portions Master Tip: Break ingredients down in the Cart-to-Recipe feature to see how fast those numbers climb. You'll be surprised how small adjustments can shave off 200+ calories.

Final Takeaway: Healthy Doesn't Mean Unlimited

These foods can absolutely fit into a smart, sustainable lifestyle, if you know how much you're actually eating. That's where the Portions Master App makes all the difference.

Visual tracking makes portion control feel natural, not obsessive. No weighing, no measuring, just a quick photo and smart feedback that helps you stay in tune with your goals.